Skip to main content
How to choose a restaurant designer - MAKET Design Studio methodology

How to Choose a Restaurant Designer: Three Questions That Shift the Conversation from Aesthetics to Methodology

Three questions most restaurateurs never ask at the first meeting - and how the answers change everything about the selection process.

June 1, 2026·11 min read
Konstantin Ostroukhov
CEO, MAKET studio · 14 years in commercial interior design

A restaurant renovation means tens of millions of rubles and three to four months of downtime. And the decision about who to trust with that money is most often made like this: they scroll through the studio's Instagram, they like the photos - let's work together.

I've spent years on the other side of this conversation - I'm the designer who gets chosen. And I know exactly how these algorithms work: why designers are chosen, and by what they are chosen - almost always by the pictures. And the stuff that matters far more than a portfolio - almost nobody asks about it: what did I measure in the dining room before starting the work, what changed for the client six months after opening, and why did I make this particular decision and not another.

It's not that restaurateurs are short-sighted. The industry just doesn't offer another tool. We designers sell photographs of finished spaces, clients evaluate them - and everyone is happy right up until the moment when a beautiful dining room somehow fails to bring in the money they were counting on.

These three questions are what I will unpack - each one separately. But first, a few words about why I consider choosing a designer a money decision in the first place, and not a question of taste.

Why this is a money decision, and not a question of taste

I will start with what has been studied best in our profession: the environment measurably drives guest behaviour. This is not "atmosphere matters" at the level of feelings - these are measured effects, and at one point they really sobered me up.

Back in 1992, Mary Jo Bitner described the concept of the "servicescape" in the Journal of Marketing: the physical environment - light, sound, layout, materials - influences the behaviour of both guest and staff no less than the service itself. It has since become one of the most cited works in services marketing.

Then came the measurements. Milliman's classic experiment (Journal of Consumer Research, 1986) in a real restaurant: with slow music, guests stayed longer and spent more at the bar, while the food bill did not change. Change the tempo of the music and behaviour changed, and revenue followed. The same goes for seating: the type of table moves both how long a guest stays and how quickly the seat frees up (Kimes & Robson, Cornell, 2004). The environment turns out to be a lever you can pull - not a backdrop.

Now about the stakes. Most independent restaurants do not survive to three years: 26% close in the first year, around 61% within three (Parsa et al., Cornell Quarterly, 2005). And here I have to be honest. In that data, the causes of failure are concept, management, lack of money, a mismatch between concept and location. Design is not among the documented causes: it was named neither as the culprit nor as the saviour. A bad interior will not kill a good concept - I have seen this. But a poorly designed dining room builds in a handicap that cannot later be overcome without new construction - and the environment, as we have just seen, really does move both behaviour and the check.

So for me, a restaurant designer is a decision with measurable financial consequences. And yet we get picked like decorators. The three questions below return the conversation to where it belongs.

A portfolio is a photo shoot. Not a business report.

When a restaurateur opens my portfolio, they see beautiful shots. What they do not see there: what happened to revenue after opening, what the table turnover looked like six months later, whether the average check went up or down.

And it's not that I'm hiding anything. A designer's contract simply ends at handover. I get photographs for the portfolio, the restaurateur gets a space and figures the rest out alone. That is how it works for everyone.

An example from practice. In one project almost the entire budget went into equipment and beautiful details, and in the end only 26 seats fit into 130 square metres. At peak hours the dining room physically could not take everyone who came in. It turned out beautiful. But the business ran below full capacity - simply because no one thought about seating efficiency before the work began.

First question: what did you measure at the site before starting the work?

This is a question about the baseline.

If a designer did not know what was happening with the business before the renovation, they cannot know what changed after. No baseline, no accountability for the result. To me it is simple: if you did not take the temperature before treatment, do not claim the pills helped.

Most studios begin with a brief: style, budget, timeline, wishes. For aesthetic work that is fine. For designing a business tool it is weak.

In the restaurateur's place, I would ask the space itself: what is the current average dwell time during the evening shift? Where does the staff lose time on the route from the kitchen to the far tables? Which zones work worse, and why there specifically? The answers say more about the layout than any references.

In our practice we build this operational matrix before any concept work begins. Target dwell time sets the seating type, the peak by time of day sets the zone configuration, and the share of alcohol in the check pulls the lighting along with it (a link I unpacked in the article on restaurant lighting). This is not complexity for its own sake. It is simply how I can explain every decision with an argument rather than a feeling.

What a strong designer can answer here: "We looked at zone occupancy by time slot, the staff route, the ratio of seating types - that was our baseline." And a weak answer is: "We work from the client's brief, that is their domain." That's honest too. It's just that now you know.

Second question: what changed six months after your project?

This question almost always produces a pause. I know, because I too was almost never asked it.

We designers are used to a different set of results: a magazine feature, an award, a client's review at handover. In a system where everything is judged by photographs, these are honest results. It is just that none of them says whether the restaurant started earning more.

From what I have observed, trends in restaurant design live three to four years. Those who chased fashion often redo the dining room before they have recouped the first renovation. An overly trend-driven interior is, in essence, money spent twice.

What a strong designer can answer here: specific changes they know or tracked. Even approximate ones - the habit itself is what matters. "The client told us that six months later people started staying longer in the evening, and it shows in the revenue. The booth section fills first." Now that is the answer of a person who thought about the outcome, and not only about delivery.

And if it is "that is the client's zone, we don't track it" - that is not the fault of any individual designer. It's the industry norm. It's just that now you know it exists.

Third question: why this specific decision, and not another?

The type of seating moves guest behaviour more than almost any other detail in the dining room. Guests are drawn to the seats along the wall - booths, corners: it is calmer there, you can see the room, but your back is covered (Robson, Journal of Environmental Psychology, 2008). And that is usually where people stay longest. An open table in the middle of the room is taken more reluctantly, but it turns over faster. The subtlety that almost everyone misses: the average check for both comes out roughly the same - what differs is the way the table earns (Kimes & Robson, Cornell, 2004). The booth brings in money through a long, cozy evening; the open table through fast turnover. What is more profitable for a given zone is decided not by taste but by its job: to hold or to turn over.

This is an operational question, not an aesthetic one. A designer who understands this will answer "where to put the booths" differently too - not because they remember the numbers by heart, but because they think in the right categories.

Every zone works this way: it exists not for the sake of a beautiful floor plan, but for the sake of a specific guest behaviour. I unpacked the mechanics of RevPASH and the logic of table mix in the article on restaurant zoning.

"Why this specific decision?" - for me this is a filter. It separates a well-trained eye from methodology. A designer ready to discuss the function of their decisions works differently from a designer running on pure intuition. Both can reach a good result. But only one can be verified.

What a strong designer can answer here is the function of the specific decision. "The booth is here because this is an evening zone, we need to hold the guest longer." Or: "The high stools at the counter are for lunch rotation, here we don't want people staying longer than forty minutes." This is not the same as "I like how it looks" or "this is how it's done now".

Why these questions are never asked

The answer is simple and uncomfortable for the whole industry, myself included.

Designers are evaluated by photographs. Competitions, publications, Instagram, ratings - all of it works with the image. A business result does not fit into the image. A designer who made a beautiful restaurant and got into Dezeen is worth more on the market than one with a less photogenic project but excellent turnover and a high check. Even if the second did something far more valuable for the business.

This is not a conspiracy. It is a hole in the system: the industry simply has no mechanism to evaluate a business result. Recommendations for evaluating a dining room after opening exist, but they never became a standard. Most contracts still contain not a single KPI tied to the money of the project.

And restaurateurs ask different questions because they do not know these ones exist. Guides online advise: look at the portfolio, check HoReCa experience, ask for references. Useful advice. It just helps you choose the best among designers who all work the same way.

The three questions in this article do not divide us into "better" and "worse". They divide us into two different approaches. Which one you need depends on the task. But a designer who was not expecting these questions and still starts talking about methodology - that, for me, is already a different conversation.

I realize this article makes my own life harder: people will grill me more strictly after it. Well, good. It matters more to me that people choose me for how I think, and not only for the beautiful shots. That is why we build the operational matrix before starting the work and look at the metrics after opening - this is what our evidence-based design is.

Want to understand the methodology?

We'll walk you through how we assess a space before starting - and how that shapes the business outcome.

Discuss a project

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you choose a restaurant designer by portfolio?

A portfolio is the first filter: HoReCa experience, project scale, aesthetics. But it is a photo shoot, not a business report. After the initial screening come three questions: what did you measure before, what changed after, why this specific decision. One filter without the other works less well.

What should you measure in a restaurant before a renovation?

Operational parameters: dwell time by time slot (lunch/evening), table turnover, zone occupancy at peak hours, the staff route from kitchen to far tables. This is your baseline. Without it, it is impossible to assess what the design actually changed.

How can you tell that a designer thinks about the business result, and not only about beauty?

Ask the three questions from this article and listen. A designer who thinks about the result names operational variables - dwell time, zone occupancy, the staff route. A designer who thinks about the portfolio talks about style, references, "concept". The reaction to the questions is more telling than a prepared presentation.

Does design affect whether a restaurant survives?

In the direct data on the causes of closures (Parsa et al., 2005), design does not appear - it is concept, management, capital, location. But the environment measurably drives guest behaviour (Bitner, 1992; Milliman, 1986), so a well-planned layout will not save a weak concept, and a weak layout will undercut a strong one. Design is not the cause of survival, but neither is it a neutral decoration.

At what stage of the selection should you ask these questions?

At the first substantive meeting - before the conversation has moved to portfolio and pricing. The designer did not prepare for them specifically, and you see the genuine reaction to an unexpected question. It is at that moment that the answers are most informative.